Influence Digest: The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides

At the heart of The Silent Patient is Alicia Berenson, a renowned artist who goes silent after being convicted of murdering her husband, Gabriel. She communicates only through a self-portrait titled Alcestis. Enter Theo Faber, a psychotherapist obsessed with uncovering Alicia’s story, determined to make her speak. As Theo delves deeper, his own dark past comes to light, culminating in the shocking revelation—he was the one stalking Alicia all along, pushing her toward the crime he was supposedly investigating.

During our discussion, reactions to the plot twist ranged from utter shock to mild disappointment. Some members admitted they didn’t see the twist coming, while others felt it wasn’t as impactful as expected. One member mentioned they anticipated a twist involving Gabriel’s lover instead, proving how successfully the book kept us guessing.

Theo’s role as both narrator and antagonist sparked intense debate. Some members found his obsession with Alicia unsettling, questioning his credibility and likening him to a “male saviour” figure. Others were frustrated by his inaction regarding his wife’s infidelity, seeing it as an odd contrast to his hyper-focus on Alicia’s trauma.

Alicia’s silence was another focal point. Was it a coping mechanism? A deliberate act of defiance? One member connected her muteness to Greek mythology, suggesting it added a layer of depth to her character. However, some felt her silence could have been explored more thoroughly, particularly in relation to her art and her relationship with Gabriel.

Beyond the twist, our discussion examined the book’s deeper themes. Obsession runs through both Alicia and Theo’s lives, manifesting in unhealthy ways. Betrayal—whether through infidelity, manipulation, or violence—was central to every character’s journey. The impact of past trauma, particularly in Theo’s case, led to a conversation about the cyclical nature of abuse and psychological scars.

Theo’s role as an unreliable narrator fueled discussion about the book’s structure. Did his manipulation of Alicia make the entire narrative untrustworthy? Some members felt that knowing his true nature in hindsight changed their perception of every event in the book. Others debated whether this added to or detracted from the suspense. One intriguing theory was whether The Silent Patient left room for a sequel exploring Theo and Kathy’s future.

By the end of the meeting, one thing was clear: The Silent Patient left a lasting impression. Whether you loved the twist or found it lacking, the book sparked conversations about the nature of storytelling, the ethics of therapy, and the psychology of silence. Our members agreed that while some aspects could have been developed further, the novel remains a compelling read that challenges the reader’s perception of truth.

For our next book club pick, we’re switching things up with a Sci-fi novel! We’re excited for the change in tone and can’t wait to see what this new genre will bring to our next meeting.

Looking for a digital and social media agency based in London to help you achieve your objectives? Get in touch here.